Episode 5: The Supreme Dumb Thing is the fifth episode of the OverBlood 2 Super Replay, which aired on January 9, 2012. The episode features Tim Turi (on controls), Andrew Reiner, Dan Ryckert, and guest Phil Kollar.
Although Ben Hanson is not officially credited as a cast member, he has a microphone for this episode (as well as the rest of this Super Replay) and offers commentary and conversation along with the rest of the crew.
Episode 5 is probably most well known for being the episode in which the Replay crew "faked" the game-ending glitch that affected certain copies of OverBlood 2. This caused some controversy among some members of the Replay fanbase, who believed that the Replay crew had "given up" on seeing the rest of OverBlood 2.
Other members of the fanbase, however, correctly guessed that the glitch was a ruse, and after skipping one update day to keep up the facade, the Replay crew aired Episode 6 of the OverBlood 2 Super Replay the subsequent Friday.
Super Replay: OverBlood 2 at Game Informer